The Worst Cup


She woke to the smell of coffee.

For a moment, still half-asleep on the floor, she just lay there with it. The smell. The specific, familiar, impossible smell of coffee in a place that did not yet have anything — no furniture, no food, no curtains, just two people and a truck parked outside, with a heat wave that had followed them the entire four hundred miles across the country.

They’d driven through it together, the two of them taking shifts behind the wheel of a 26-foot box truck loaded with everything she owned, stopping once at a housewares store to buy the things you need when you’re starting over somewhere new… with someone new. A coffee machine. A grinder. A shower curtain. Hope, basically, in object form.

By the time they’d made it upstairs it was a hundred and five degrees and she was wrung out in the way you only get after a day of finally finishing doing something hard with someone you trust. They hadn’t unpacked. They hadn’t eaten. They’d grabbed blankets from the truck, crashed on the floor side by side, and been asleep before they’d said goodnight.

So. Coffee. Impossible.

She sat up. Through the doorway she could see him in the kitchen — Ben, her lifemate of three hours, a man she had known for years in the easy, backgrounded way you know someone before you actually let them in. He was standing at the counter with the focused expression of a person defusing something, peering at the brand-new coffee machine like it owed him an explanation.

He’d woken up before her. Gone down to the truck. Found the machine and the grinder in their boxes, still wrapped in plastic. Driven to the grocery store for coffee because there was none. Came back. Figured out the machine. Made her coffee in a house where they’d been asleep on the floor just an hour ago.

He didn’t even drink coffee. Never had. Never would.

“Morning,” he said, when he heard her. He held out the cup like a peace offering. Like it was nothing. Like people did this kind of thing all the time.

The coffee was terrible.

She wanted to be clear about this: it was genuinely, profoundly, hall-of-famingly terrible. Weak and burnt at once, which shouldn’t be physically possible. Grounds floating at the surface. A flavor that suggested the machine had been personally offended by the whole enterprise and retaliated. For the better part of a decade it held the record as the worst cup of coffee she’d ever had in her life. He never got better at it — not once, not with practice, not even later with a pod machine that made excellence essentially automatic. Whatever gift for coffee-making exists in the human brain, Ben did not have it, has never had it, may never have it.

She held the cup in both hands and drank every last drop.

She stood in their empty kitchen — floor bare, walls bare, the whole apartment still just an idea of itself — she drank the terrible coffee and looked at him feeling something shift in her chest. Something quiet and tectonic and total. The kind of shift you don’t have words for in the moment. The kind you spend years walking toward before you finally turn around and see where it started. He was the one. He was the one, indeed.

It had started here. With the worst cup of coffee she’d ever tasted, made by someone who didn’t drink coffee, in a kitchen they’d owned for three hours, on a floor they’d slept on because they were too tired and too happy to care about anything else.

She would tell this story at their wedding. The whole room would laugh — not because it was funny, exactly, but because it was so completely, perfectly them. Nobody was surprised by the terrible coffee. Nobody was surprised that this was the moment. Nobody was surprised that it took them years and years to figure out what had been true since the very first day they met.

Here is what she knows now, that she couldn’t have named then:

Love doesn’t always look like a grand gesture. Sometimes it looks like someone waking up before you, in an unfamiliar place, and deciding that you deserve a warm cup of coffee — even if they have to go get the beans themselves, even if they’ve never used the machine, even if it turns out terrible. It looks like trying. It looks like the fact that it didn’t occur to him not to.

It was the worst coffee she’d ever had.

And yet… she has never loved a cup more.


✦ Today’s Reflection

When did someone you love do something impractical, imperfect, and completely unnecessary for you — and when did you realize it was one of the most loving thing anyone had ever done?

Stay connected for weekly heart-to-hearts on the beautiful, messy reality of being a witch in today’s world. I’m diving into everything from magical burnout and the weight of emotional labor to finding romance when your energy feels spent.

If you’re a witch who is feeling a bit spiritually drained but still showing up for your craft and your life..come join us!

Thank you for subscribing!

Please check your email to confirming your subscription.

Leave a comment